Literacy Strategies for the Science Classroom
Author: | Jeffrey Edwards |
Level: | High School |
Content Area: | Science |
Author: | Jeffrey Edwards |
Level: | High School |
Content Area: | Science |
Note: see the attached "BT Corn Debate.pdf" document for all materials referenced on this page.
In this lesson students are introduced to the debate on the use of Genetically Modified Organisms (GMO’s) as a food source by reading the New York Times article entitled “Both Sides Cite Science to Address Altered Corn”. This article gives an unbiased look into the debate. From the information gained in the article students begin to draw their own conclusions about whether or not it poses threat to the environment. Students should then research the topic of using Bt corn are asked to write a short paper defending their stance on the issue. This activity is appropriate for a general high school biology class or can be modified for honors or AP biology.
National Standards addressed by this lesson include content standards for grades 9-12 for the Life Sciences. Fundamental concepts include the molecular basis for heredity and the interdependence of organisms.
Classroom time will vary based upon the amount of time given to students for research. Some may introduce the lesson during a single 50 min class period and assign the research and writing phases as an independent homework assignment. Others may want to provide students with an additional time for supervised research using library or internet resources.
Students should have been introduced, through the use of their biology text, to the use of GMO’s and how GMO’s are produced prior to introducing this lesson. The Instructor should also have students preview article for any unfamiliar vocabulary beyond that included in the critical vocabulary section. Frayer charts are used to assist students in understanding new vocabulary that may be found in the article. Information on using Frayer charts can be found in the resources section.
Engage students with a brief introduction of how science may provide insight into “how” something can be done, the practice of science itself does not provide us with the ethics of “should” it be done. Review with students the process of creating genetically modified organism. Allow students to discussion their own feelings on the issue prior to reading the article or doing any research into the topic. Many students may have misconceptions that come to light during this discussion. Have students write their feelings allowing them to uncover their own misconceptions during their research. You as the instructor may want to make notes of any of these misconceptions do return to later in concluding the lesson to assure that the student has corrected them during their research.
Direct students to read the article and to carefully consider both sides of the issue before proceeding on to the next phase of the lesson. Students should take notes as they are reading on the graphic organizer provided.
Have students briefly discuss the notes taken from their reading. Ask if anyone has changed their point of view. Explain that this is a carefully debated issue in many parts of the world due to food shortages and concerns of local populations.
During this portion of the lesson students are to write their own persuasive essay either for or against the use of genetically modified organisms. Students should provide at least three pieces of evidence in support of their stance on the issue. The opposing argument should also be addressed in the essay. Further internet research by the student will be required and students should be encouraged to use the “Debate over BT Corn” graphic organizer in completing their research. If students have not had practice in this type of writing the teacher may want to use the “Persuasive Essay Outline” with the entire class, otherwise it may be used for differentiation to scaffold those students who may have difficulty in preparing their paper.
Students will be evaluated on their ability to support their particular stance on use of GMO’s with scientific data. Students will write a persuasive paper in support of their chosen stance on the issue. Students should be directed to use reliable sources in seeking support for their particular stance.
Use the grading rubric provided to assess student expectations for the persuasive essay.
Students may be allowed to present their essay to the class andIf time allows the instructor may wish to allow students to conduct a class debate on the selected topic. Students may also be encouraged to share their essay in small group discussions or before the entire class.
none
These are the terms with which students seem to have the most difficulty, since the English standard course of study emphasized etymology of word this information is provided where it could be found.
A sample outline for a persuasive paper is provided to assist students in planning their paper.