It seems like many issues surrounding education tend to foster really strong support at opposite ends of the proverbial spectrum. Being an early elementary teacher I do not really have to deal with the issue of social media use in the classroom. My students do not carry smartphones and they are not old enough to sign up for accounts on social networking websites. I think that the use of social media in the classroom entertains such polar viewpoints because the Internet can be a little bit scary. I think that some educators are willing to pass up social media as a learning tool because to them the liability involved outweighs the reward. In an age where every other story on the news is about another teen bullied via cyberspace, I think it is understandable that some educators and local policy makers say “no thank you” to social media. As a teacher, you feel a huge responsibility for your students’ well being. If something terrible were to happen to one of your students because of social media activity associated with your classroom you would most likely feel tremendously responsible for it (additionally, your integrity as an educator would perhaps be questioned by outsiders).
I assume that those on the pro-social media side of the argument set their students up to act responsibly in cyberspace and communicate clear expectations for the use of social media and electronic devices in their classrooms. If they have put the time and effort into a management system that works I don’t see any reason why they shouldn’t be allowed to use social media in the classroom. Social media definitely has compelling pros when it comes to access to instant feedback for students and distance learning.
Basically, I don’t think that this is the type of issue where there is one correct answer. I think that if you are willing to put the time in to developing responsible ways to use social media in the classroom to enhance student engagement and learning, then you should be allowed to use social media in the classroom.